0 items in Cart
Pizza on 23 Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Pizza on 23 Online Ordering Menu

221 E 23rd St
New York, NY 10010
(646) 476-5006
Closed
Announcement
Store's closed until further notice due to maintenance.
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

APPETIZERS & SIDE ORDERS

Garlic Bread 
$2.75
Garlic Bread with Cheese 
$3.50
Garlic Knots (5) 
$1.75
Mozzarella Sticks (6) 
$5.95
Chicken Fingers (6) 
$7.50
Chicken Fingers with French Fries 
$9.75
Fried Zucchini 
$5.25
Fried Calamari 
$9.00
Jalapeño Poppers (7) 
$6.95
French Fries 
$3.50
Chicken Tenders (5) 
$8.00
Side of Meatballs 
$5.00
Side of Sausage 
$5.00

SALADS

Choice of dressing: ranch, blue cheese, balsamic vinaigrette, olive oil & vinegar, French, creamy Italian, or Caesar.
Garden Salad 
$5.00+
Caesar Salad 
$7.00
Chicken Caesar Salad 
$9.50
Greek Salad 
$8.00
Greek Chicken Salad 
$10.50
Chef Salad 
$8.50
Antipasto Salad 
$8.50
Caprese Salad 
Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and balsamic vinegar.
$10.00
Tuna Salad 
$8.50

SOUPS

All served with bread.
Tomato Soup 
$4.00
Minestrone Soup 
$4.00
Chicken Soup 
$4.00
Broccoli Soup 
$4.00

HOT WINGS

Buffalo Wings with Blue Cheese & Celery 
$7.95
Buffalo Wings & French Fries 
$9.96

COLD SUBS

With cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and oil & vinegar.
Italian Sub 
Ham, capicola, salami, and provolone cheese.
$7.95
Tuna Sub 
$6.50
Ham Sub 
$6.50
Turkey Sub 
$7.50
Salami 
$6.50
Capicola 
$6.50
Vegetarian 
$6.50
Chicken Ranch 
Chicken breast, ranch, mozzarella, jalapeños, and red onions.
$7.95

HOT SUBS

All with cheese.
Chicken Parmigiana Sub 
$8.50
Veal Parmigiana Sub 
$8.50
Meatball Sub 
$7.95
Sausage Sub 
$7.95
Eggplant Sub 
$7.95
Buffalo Chicken Sub 
$8.95
Chicken Cheesesteak Sub 
American cheese, peppers, and onions.
$8.95
Cheesesteak Sub 
American cheese, peppers, and onions.
$8.95

CHEESEBURGERS

With lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Cheeseburger 
$5.85
Deluxe Cheeseburger 
$7.95
Cheeseburger with Bacon 
$6.95
Deluxe Cheeseburger with Bacon 
$8.95

PASTA

With garlic bread and choice of spaghetti, linguini, fettuccine, or penne.
Pasta with Marinara Sauce 
$7.95
Pasta with Meatball 
$9.50
Pasta with Meat Sauce 
$9.50
Pasta with Sausage 
$9.50
Pasta with Garlic & Oil 
$8.25
Pasta with Mushrooms, Garlic & Oil 
$9.25
Tortellini with Pesto Sauce 
$9.50
Tortellini with Marinara Sauce 
$9.00
Penne Arrabbiata 
$9.95
Baked Ziti 
$8.95
Lasagna 
$9.50
Cheese Ravioli 
$8.95
Manicotti 
$8.95
Pasta Combo 
Lasagna, ravioli, and manicotti.
$10.00
Spaghetti Carbonara 
Cream sauce and bacon.
$9.50
Tortellini Primavera 
All veggies.
$10.95
Penne Alla Vodka 
$9.50
Fettuccine Alfredo 
$9.50

SPECIALTY DISHES

With garlic bread and choice of spaghetti, linguini, fettuccine, or penne.
Chicken Marsala 
Marsala wine and mushrooms.
$13.95
Chicken Picatta 
White wine and capers.
$13.95
Chicken Cacciatore 
Peppers, onions, and mushrooms.
$13.95
Fettuccine Chicken Alfredo 
$13.95
Tortellini Chicken Alfredo 
$13.95
Fettuccine Chicken Primavera 
$13.95
Tortellini Chicken Primavera 
$13.95
Chicken Francese 
$12.95

SEAFOOD DISHES

With garlic bread and choice of spaghetti, linguini, fettuccine, or penne.
Shrimp Scampi 
$14.50
Shrimp Fettuccine Alfredo 
$14.50
Calamari Marinara 
$13.95
Pasta with Clam Sauce 
Red or white.
$9.50

PIZZA SLICES

Cheese Slice 
$2.75+
Sicilian Slice 
$3.00+
One-Topping Slice 
$3.50+
Two-Topping Slice 
$4.00+
White Slice 
$3.50+
Margherita Slice 
Fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil.
$3.50+
Special Slice 
Meats & veggies.
$4.25+
Vegetarian Slice 
All veggies.
$4.25+
Buffalo Chicken Slice 
$4.25+
BBQ Chicken Slice 
$4.25+
Stuffed Special Pizza on 23rd Slice 
$5.50+

PIZZA PIES

Cheese Pizza 
$6.95+
One-Topping Pizza 
$7.45+
Two-Topping Pizza 
$9.95+
White Pizza 
$11.95+
Margherita Pizza 
Fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and tomato sauce.
$11.95+
Chicken Pesto Pizza 
$11.95+
Hawaiian Pizza 
$11.95+
Meatlovers Pizza 
$12.95+
Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza 
$17.95+
Buffalo Chicken Pizza 
$11.95+
BBQ Chicken Pizza 
$11.95+
Florentine Chicken Pizza 
Fresh spinach, Alfredo sauce, roasted garlic, and mozzarella cheese.
$17.95+
Special Pizza 
Meats and veggies.
$12.95+
Vegetarian Pizza 
Veggies.
$12.95+
Chicken Ranch Pizza 
Ranch dressing, mushrooms, and red onions.
$12.95+
Vodka Sauce Pizza 
Fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, basil, and olive oil.
$17.95+
Stuffed Special Pizza on 23rd 
Ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni, peppers, and onions.
$17.95+

CALZONES

Cheese Calzone 
$5.95+
One-Filling Calzone 
$6.95+
Specialty Calzone 
$7.95+

PIZZA ROLLS

Pepperoni Pizza Roll 
$5.95
Meatball Pizza Roll 
$5.95
Sausage Pizza Roll 
$5.95
Chicken Pizza Roll 
$5.95
Spinach Pizza Roll 
$5.95
Eggplant Pizza Roll 
$5.95

DESSERTS

Tiramisu 
$4.00
Italian Cheesecake 
$4.00
Canoli 
$4.00
Chocolate Cake 
$4.00

DRINKS

Bottle of Water 
$1.50
Can Soda 
Coca-Cola products.
$1.25
20oz Soda 
Coca-Cola products.
$2.00
2-Liter Soda 
Coca-Cola products.
$3.00
Snapple 
$2.00

CATERING

*Must order 24 hours in advance.
Garden Salad 
$28.00+
Greek Salad 
$33.00+
Chicken Caesar Salad 
$57.00+
Chef Salad 
$33.00+
Antipasto Salad 
$47.00+
Lasagna 
$37.00+
Baked Ziti 
$37.00+
Chicken Parmigiana 
$47.00+
Veal Parmigiana 
$47.00+
Eggplant Parmigiana 
$40.00+
Pasta with Meatball 
$47.00+
Pasta with Sausage 
$47.00+
Chicken Marsala 
$50.00+
Chicken Picatta 
$50.00+
Veal Marsala 
$60.00+
Veal Picatta 
$60.00+
Shrimp Scampi 
$70.00+

ITALIAN PARTY SUB

*Must order 24 hours in advance.
Italian Party Sub 
3 foot or 6 foot.
$52.00+
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


Powered by Menufy © 2021
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.